Wi-LAN initiates patent lawsuits against 22 companies
Wi-LAN is at it again. The Canadian licensing company, which some call a patent troll, has initiated two patent infringement lawsuits against 22 different companies over WiFi and DSL. The suits were filed in the Eastern District of Texas, where companies like to bring in lawsuits because of the courts reputation for moving swiftly on patent cases and awarding some fat damages to patent holders. Wi-LAN is charging infringement on three of its patents, two of which related to WiFi technology and one that has to do with power consumption on DSL products.
The companies being sued include some big names: Apple, Dell, Intel, Texas Instruments, Sony, Lenovo, Broadcom, Acer, Best Buy and Circuit City. During a conference call last week, Wi-LAN CEO Jim Skippen said Wi-LAN has plenty of funds to go after companies it says infringe on the company's patents.
Wi-LAN said it chose to sue now before it faces pre-emptive lawsuits from these companies. "We were concerned that we would be forced into other courts through declaratory-judgment actions if we did not sue virtually all of the likely defendants," Skippen said.
In 2005, Cisco and Wi-LAN settled their patent dispute. As part of the settlement, Cisco bought some, but not all, of the Wi-LAN's patents. Analysts at the time expected more lawsuits to come.
For more about Wi-LAN's suit against these 22 companies:
- read this article from Dow Jones
- take a look at this analysis from Tech dirt Wireless blog
Comments (3) | Post a comment
Comments
Posted by Anonymous | November 5, 2007 - 3:32pm
If Wi-LAN is a patent troll what do you call Qualcomm? a Patent Behemoth??
It is high time US patents laws and processes be revamped to allow more unincumbered technology advances introduced in North America rather than going overseas to introduce them.
American Lawyers stike again but this time it comes from outside the country and it's all so wrong.
Posted by Lynnette Luna | November 8, 2007 - 3:01pm
There is no comparison between Qualcomm and Wi-LAN. Qualcomm actually makes CDMA chips and other equipment. Wi-LAN doesn't have any intention of making products. It just sues. I totally agree with you that U.S. patent laws and processes be revamped.
Posted by Anonymous | March 25, 2008 - 4:36pm
Respect the power and authority of the USPTO. If we dont, then no one will.
some hard science and research went into drafting the patent and real people were working behind the scenes.
I, for one, would hate to see a US patent over-turned or marked unenforceable just because some big companies think that the technology is now public domain. It's not. And it never really was.
